The books lay the groundwork for Harry's relationship with Cho all the way back in "Prisoner of Azkaban" when his crush is first revealed. The films change a few things about Cho Chang, including the fact that she's a year older than the trio, but the biggest inconsistencies are in her relationship with Harry. Movie-Harry should've been able to see the Thestrals after his first year even if book-Harry couldn't.ĭaniel Radcliffe and Katie Leung in "Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix." In the book, he was unconscious when Professor Quirrell died, so he didn't actually witness the death - but in the film he was awake. But what's not explained is why he couldn't see them after Professor Quirrell's death in "Sorcerer's Stone." It's easy to assume that Harry was too young to comprehend his mother's death as an infant, and that's why he couldn't see Thestrals in his first year at Hogwarts. Harry saw Cedric Diggory die at the end of his fourth school year, so that makes sense, but he should've been able to see them before then since he witnessed the deaths of his mother as a baby and Professor Quirrell in his first year at Hogwarts. Luna explains this mystery by telling everyone that you can only see them if you've witnessed death. In "Order of the Phoenix," we learn that Harry can see the creatures, but Hermione and Ron can't. Thestrals are magical beings primarily used in the books to pull carriages of students to Hogwarts from Hogsmede.
People can only see Thestrals if they've witnessed someone dying. uses Polyjuice Potion to impersonate Mad-Eye Moody in the fourth movie, his voice seemingly does transform. The inconsistencies continue when you take into account that when Barty Crouch Jr. That also creates a discrepancy in "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 1" when Hermione uses Polyjuice Potion to become Harry and remarks on how terrible his eyesight is.Īdditionally, Ron and Harry maintain their own voices in the second movie, which is consistent with the characters who become Harry in the first "Deathly Hallows" film, but still inconsistent with the book's description. But this isn't what we see play out in the films.įor one thing, in the second movie, Harry (as Goyle) keeps his glasses on until Draco questions it, insinuating that he doesn't get Goyle's vision from drinking the potion.
This clearly tells readers that under the effects of the potion you take on both the vision and voice of the person you've become. Then he realized that his glasses were clouding his eyes because Goyle obviously didn't need them - he took them off and called, 'Are you two okay?' Goyle's low rasp of a voice issued from his mouth." When Ron and Harry use Polyjuice Potion to transform into Crabbe and Goyle in the second book, Harry's thoughts read, ". It's unclear whether the potion changes people's voices.
0 kommentar(er)
